The Best Online Diamond Buyers

Last updated: September 22, 2021
Diamond Buyers
Looking to buy pre-owned diamonds?
Worthy is now offering an exclusive opportunity for select consumers to purchase recycled diamonds.
Click here to learn more about the Recycled Diamonds Project.

How to Choose Trustworthy Diamond Buyers Near You

If you’re looking for a trustworthy company to help you sell your diamonds, Worthy should be your first and last stop. We are highly familiar with the diamond market and well-known amongst diamond buyers, meaning you can trust your diamonds will be well treated and that we will get you the highest price possible.

The pre-owned diamond market is an intricate and complicated sphere. Buyers with teams of experienced professionals and an exhaustive knowledge of the market are most likely to offer you the best prices for your stones.

Worthy also has years of accrued experience in diamond grading, partnering with some of the nation's top grading labs. We sell diamonds successfully through our online platform. It’s understandable to question whether or not an online platform is a safe place to entrust your diamonds. However, our years of experience, professional connections in the diamond market, and high-quality process for preparing to sell your diamonds mean you can trust us.

Knowing diamonds inside and out as we do puts us in the perfect position to know exactly what your stones are worth. Take a look at some of the key features that set Worthy apart and make us the best online diamond buyers for you.

Benefits of Selling to Diamond Buyers

Quick Transaction Turnover

One of the main benefits of selling your gems through a buyers network like Worthy is all the time you save. We can close deals within a couple of days, and the transfer of your payment shouldn’t take more than 48 hours. We want to help you close a sale quickly and safely, which is why our network of buyers is the perfect solution. In no time, you'll gain access to some of the highest potential proposals for your diamond.

First, we will come back to you with a market value estimate of your diamond based on your written description. Next, your diamond will be picked up by a FedEx courier free of charge and fully insured until transferred to the selected diamond buyer. We will handle the entire process with the diamond buyers for you. Once the final buyer is decided, the transaction is managed by Worthy, and your money will be transferred to you quickly and efficiently.

Guaranteed Security for your Diamonds

Your diamonds are significant monetarily and for sentimental reasons. At Worthy, our buyers operate according to strict rules and procedures in order to guarantee the security of your precious stones. We insure diamonds while they are in transit and follow best practices, including video-taping the handling of packages from the sellers and ensuring that their administrative centers have extremely tight security with highly trained employees.

When you commission Worthy to find you the best offer for your diamond, you are putting your property in safe and experienced hands. Worthy has all certifications and licenses. From the moment you ship your diamonds to us, they are fully insured through ParcelPro and Delta Lloyd until they are purchased for the best price and reach the selected buyer.

Our Buyers Pay Top Market Prices

You deserve top-dollar prices and offers on your stones. We can get you that at Worthy. We have a network of diamond buyers who are well-connected to the best diamond markets across the United States. Our strong business-to-business relationship management makes this possible and subsequently makes it possible for you to receive higher value-priced offers on your diamonds.

Full Transparency During the Process

You shouldn’t have to compromise on fairness or honesty. Trustworthy, honest, and reputable diamond buyers work according to a methodical procedure of grading diamonds to obtain fair and regulated pricing. Valuation should be completely transparent, and with, it is. We will explain exactly how the selling price for your diamond was calculated.

Our highly transparent valuation process begins with a brief description of the seller’s diamond via our website, including uploaded photos of the gem. We will survey the market and send you an initial estimate so you know where you stand. Once the diamond arrives at Worthy's headquarters, it will be evaluated by one of our certified graders to affirm all diamond characteristics. Once you are aware of the final asking price, it will then be released to our network of diamond buyers for bidding.


You shouldn’t trust your diamonds with a company that lacks experience and knowledge. For years, Worthy has worked to build up a reputation that speaks for itself. We use this experience and intimate knowledge of the diamond market to benefit our customers. You can trust that our team knows exactly what they’re doing, and from start to finish, you will know that your diamonds will be taken care of and receive the best offers possible.

How Our Buyers Determine Offers For Your Diamond

The more you know your diamond, the better prepared you’ll be when approaching an auction house like Worthy. But even if you don’t know much about your particular stone, you can trust us to help you learn. Diamonds are graded on certain characteristics. How they rank within these characteristics is what determines their ultimate value. Part of our process of selling your diamond includes having it graded on these characteristics by a certified diamond laboratory.

Evaluation of your diamond is based on "The Four Cs," which are clarity, cut, color, and carat weight. Here is a breakdown of each:

  • Carat weight: Most diamond owners know the carat weight of their stone because it refers to its size. The larger the diamond, the greater the carat weight and overall value.

  • Color: Diamond evaluators and buyers also pay attention to the color of a diamond. Contrary to common assumptions, most diamonds are not totally colorless. They most often have hints of yellow or brown. Completely colorless diamonds have a higher value.

  • Clarity: This refers to the lack of nicks and blemishes on the diamond. The fewer blemishes the diamond has, the higher its value will be.

  • Cut: This is the shape the jewelry designer has given the diamond. Because modern diamonds have near-perfect lines, their value is higher than antique diamonds since their cuts are more accurate.

Sell Your Diamond Today

At Worthy, we are connected to America’s most trusted network of diamond buyers and are truly the best diamond buyers near you. Our professionalism and customer service are second to none. Whether you’re looking to sell loose diamonds or trying to find used diamond ring buyers, we can help. Contact us today to learn more about how we can help you get the best price for your diamonds.

Share this page: